Lidl organization business

As a manager:

Managers have a range of responsibilities in businesses, but one of the most crucial is interacting with direct reports in order to help their organizations accomplish and exceed their objectives. Options that are suitable for one venture may be entirely inappropriate for another. Entrepreneurs must make a staggering number of decisions, all of which must be the best for them. The framework I describe here, as well as the supporting rules of thumb, will assist entrepreneurs in analyzing their current conditions, prioritizing the opportunities and issues they face, and making sensible decisions about the future. This paradigm, which is based on my eight-year observations of hundreds of start-up businesses, does not provide answers. Instead, it aids entrepreneurs in posing pertinent questions, identifying critical difficulties, and evaluating potential solutions. Whether the business is a small printing shop attempting to remain afloat or a catalogue retailer seeking hundreds of millions of dollars in sales, the structure applies. It can be used at practically any stage of a company’s development. Entrepreneurs should utilize the framework to assess their company’s situation and direction on a regular basis, not just when issues arise.

First, I think about my organization as a manager

• Recognize the Reasons behind Our Desire to Move
• Find a path that is feasible for us.
• I will give you my whole support.
• Encourage me to try a new project.

Selected organization

LIDL

Lidl maintains market-leading value by continuously improving its efficient procedures, and this is where the Organization department focuses its efforts. This team is continually collaborating with various departments across the company to help them improve their processes, and it is, of course, constantly attempting to improve its own. Lidl is dedicated to looking after its employees not only at work but also in their personal lives. This means that their benefits package encompasses more than just the excellent pay they provide. They’ve included a few here, but they can learn about all of their benefits on their Life at Lidl organization page.

A

Total cost of moving from A to B

Moving	Place A	Place B
2022	$301.5 billion (2020)	$607.2 billion (2022)

Grocery products	$50 billion	$100 billion
Beauty products	$100 billion	$200 billion
Fast food	$70 billion	$140 billion
Fruits	$31 billion	$65 billion
Vegetables	Vegetables 50 billion	$104 billion

B

Total cost (lost revenue) in not moving

After announcing a 21.1 million ($32.1 million) deficit for the 2020-21 financial year, the British business of German discount supermarket Lidl said on Thursday that it is focused squarely on long-term opportunity rather than short-term profit.

So the total cost for moving point A to B is $607 billion and the loss is $32.1 million.

Number of employees (HO)	450	584	657	879	840
Number of employees (RDC)	3077	3403	4480	4565	4795
Number of employees (store)	12459	14110	15431	16654	16982
Amount of graduates		12	31	33	35
Number of INT trainees		3	10	20	8
Number of placement students			14	19	17
Total employees (M/F)	60/40	59/41	59/41	57/43	57/43
Management position	77/23	75/25	74/26	74/26	76/24

C

Cost of introducing business, improvement and not moving

Lidl focuses on penetration price since it is a discounter. Low prices that lead to increased sales are known as penetration pricing. There are times when Lidl’s business is less costly than other supermarkets.

Food waste (2019, 2020, 2021)

Food waste	2019	2020	2021
Food surplus	38617	37701	41790
Food surplus redistributed	469	533	1850
Redistributed impact metric (meals donated)	1116689	1269073	4404850
Food waste to anaerobic digestion	38148	37168	39940
Food waste per store	47.7	41.4	40.9

Operational waste (2019, 2020, 2021)

Operational waste	2019	2020	2021
General waste	12830	11639	15116
cardboard	81762	98726	102184
plastic	3595	4322	3956

Plastic packaging (2020, 2021)

Plastic package	2020	2021
Primary plastic packaging-TOTAL	57474	59593
Primary plastic packaging- OWN BRAND	51297	51958
Primary plastic packaging- per €1 m, net turnover (own brand)	9.14	8.41
Secondary plastic packaging	2084	1770
Tertiary plastic packaging	2302	1872

Lidl organization yearly sales comparisons (2019-2020-2021)
Sale	Open	High	Low	Close	Volume	Adj Close
2/1/2019	127.03	137.48	127.01	136.99	31,400,800	136.990005
1/3/2019	115.8	122.44	114.76	121.35	30,607,400	120.826149
12/1/2020	110.37	118.02	108.25	115.82	30,445,600	115.320023
11/1/2020	113.46	113.77	104.08	110.52	36,072,200	110.0429
10/3/2020	112.71	118.69	112.28	113.54	33,968,200	112.472404
9/1/2021	106.14	116.18	102.53	113.05	47,828,300	111.987015
8/1/2020	104.41	110.23	104	106.1	28,686,500	105.102364
7/1/2020	95.49	104.55	94.37	104.21	35,675,600	102.673927
6/1/2020	99.02	101.89	91.5	95.6	37,040,500	94.190842
5/2/2020	93.97	100.73	89.47	99.86	44,886,900	98.388046
4/1/2021	108.78	112.39	92.51	93.74	44,806,000	91.799339
3/1/2021	97.65	110.42	97.42	108.99	35,088,000	106.73362

Selected organization: LIDL

Model

Introduction

The purpose of this study is to demonstrate a United Kingdom MNC’s business strategy for worldwide growth. The firm chosen for this assignment is Lidl of the United Kingdom. The company is in the retail sector, and the retail business of various consumer items was chosen as the most profitable target market. A summary of the company and its global expansion is offered in the first few sections. The next section discusses the company’s perspective on global target markets as well as the reasons behind its selection. In order to calculate the company’s overall profit, build the objective function using process data and it’s significant to find out the financial impact. In the two last parts, potential obstacles related to subsidiaries’ operating circumstances in the chosen markets are detailed, and suitable solutions based on the concerns uncovered are recommended.

Lidl marketing strategy

LIDL’s fundamental technique is to utilize a ton of private names and offer great things to their clients. Eggs, meat, milk, new foods grown from the ground, and heated merchandise are the most famous private-mark things. These things represent over 80% of all deals.

Mission

They want:

• To offer exceptional client assistance.
• Maintaining the quality and value of our market-driving products by constantly inventing and refining our efficient cycles, which are regulated by innovation and individuals.
• To lay out long haul associations with corporate accomplices while additionally goodly affecting nearby networks.
• We will actually want to make long-haul progress by putting resources into our representatives’ enlistment, preparation, and advancement.

Vision

They strive to improve our clients’ lives by providing high-quality items at a competitive price while putting customer satisfaction at the forefront of all they do.

Company assessments

Lidl was the best-performing discounter, with a growth of 12.5 per cent and a market share of 6.1 per cent. Lidl has 53 shops in the United States but has yet to achieve its goal due to a lack of execution capacity. Pakistan might be a lucrative market for the company since it sells home equipment in retail stores. This is due to customers’ eagerness to spend money on readily accessible consumer items. Lidl is a well-known retailer in the United Kingdom. It snatched the UK’s 6% market share. This discussion suggests that Lidl, in other words, can expand its business in Pakistan in order to generate profitable returns.

Profitability Ratios

In terms of profitability, Lidl’s business items sold more, but operational expenditures climbed by a larger percentage as the years went by (Kimmel & Weygandt, 2021). As a consequence, Lidl’s profitability dropped from 0.489 in 2019 to 0.3 in 2020, resulting in a drop in return on equity. It rose somewhat in 2021 to 0.354. In 2021, the profit margin dropped from 0.267 to 0.217.

It remained at 0.217 for the third year in a row. The asset turnover dropped from 0.975 in 2012 to 0.8923 in 2019 and then to 0.833 in 2020 as a result of the decline in value. Decreased earnings in 2021 are evidence of a fall in the company’s effectiveness in generating such profits. 

Total profit of Lidl business

Lidl business
Statement of profit( Figures in thousands of USD)
					Horizontal  analysis
Item		27-Sep-19	28-Sep-19	29-Sep-20	2019-2020	2020-2021
Net Income		39,510,000	37,037,000	41,733,000	-0.1125	0.0668
Cash Flows from Operating Activities
Depreciation		7,946,000	6,757,000	3,277,000	1.0619	0.176
Adjustments To Net Income		5,210,000	3,394,000	6,145,000	-0.4477	0.5351
Changes In Accounts Receivables		-6,452,000	-1,949,000	-6,965,000	-0.7202	2
Changes In Liabilities		13,408,000	8,320,000	9,843,000	-0.1547	0.6115
Changes In Inventories		-76,000	-973,000	-15,000	63.8667	-0.9219
Changes In Other Operating Activities		167,000	1,080,000	-3,162,000	1.3416	-0.8454
Total Cash Flow From Operating Activities		59,713,000	53,666,000	50,856,000	0.0553	0.1127
Cash Flows from Investing Activities
Capital Expenditures		-9,571,000	-8,165,000	-8,295,000	-0.0157	0.1722
Investments		-9,017,000	24,042,000	38,427,000	-0.3743	0.6249
Other Cash flows from Investing Activities		-3,991,000	-1,567,000	-1,505,000	0.0412	1.5470
Total Cash Flows From Investing Activities		-22,579,00	-33,774,00	-48,227,00	-0.2997	-0.331
Cash Flows from Financing Activities
Dividends Paid		-11,126,00	-10,564,00	-2,488,000	3.2460	0.0532
Sale Purchase of Stock		-44,270,00	-22,330,00	665,000	-32.578	0.9825
Net Borrowings & financing activities		17,108,000	15,814,000	-1,226,000	13.8989	0.0818
Total Cash Flows From Financing Activities		-37,549,00	-16,379,00	-1,698,000	8.6461	1.2925
Change In Cash and Cash Equivalents		-415,000	3,513,000	931,000	2.7734	-1.118

Profit margins fell to 11.25 per cent in 2019 and then rose to 6.68 per cent in the last years of the company’s life cycle. During 2020 and 2021, the cash flows from operational operations rose by 5.53% and 11.27%, respectively. There was a 29.97 per cent drop in investment cash flows in 2019 and an additional 33.15 per cent drop in the following year. There was an 864.61 per cent growth in finance in 2019 and a 129.25 per cent increase in financing activities in 2020. There was a 277.34 per cent yearly growth in the net cash flow in 2020 and a reduction of 111.81% in 2019. Over the last three years, dividend payments have declined by 324.6 per cent, with an increase of 5.32% expected in 2020. A drop of 3257.89 per cent was seen in 2019, and a rise of 98.25 per cent was seen in 2020 in the sale and acquisition of the stock. Changes in liabilities fell by 15.47 per cent in 2019 and rose by 61.15 per cent in 2021, respectively. After a 37.43 per cent drop in investment cash flows in 2019, they fell by a further 62.49 per cent in 2019. A company’s financing activity shows increased investments. 

Sales Forecast for Lidl Inc.

Horizontal and vertical analysis shows a growth of 7.2% and an increase of 7% for Lidl sales in the first and second periods, respectively. The average of the two is 7.1%, which may be used to anticipate sales growth over the following several years. Assuming current trends continue, we estimate that sales revenue will rise to $195,773,445. According to our sales estimate increase of 7.1 per cent, we could also predict 2020 sales revenues by multiplying 2019 sales revenues by 1.071 to reach $209,673,360.

Product identification

Lidl has built a manager structure for its company. Management treats its employees like cogs in a machine and shows little regard for their contributions. This is the primary reason why Lidl, with over 8000 locations, has struggled to establish a positive market reputation. Two out of every three items in our long-lasting reach are obtained from British makers, and a fifth of Lidl items sold in Scotland are made in Scotland. More than 1800 British-made products are presently accessible, including our own-image eggs, milk, cream, margarine, new hamburger, and new poultry.

Location recognition

Lidl has a, to some degree level, hierarchical culture, with the board empowering and remunerating workers’ drive and desire. Since the objective of this administration style is to set deal goals with worker support rather than directing procedures starting from the top, a level administration structure is allowable.

Financial health

During the financial year 2019, February 28, 2022, Lidl Great Britain Limited had a turnover of $8.825 billion US dollars. Since 2013, when the company’s turnover was 212.2 million pounds, it has grown dramatically.

General about company

Factor condition

The fact that new markets are exposed to distinct business variables could be a factor condition of international expansion. Lidl has the opportunity to build a new consumer base outside of Germany in order to expand its business (Xiao, 2017). Accessing new markets would help enterprises in their specific industry expand their global market share. Furthermore, enterprises can quickly access open borders in uncontested markets.

Demand condition

 Another important aspect of the demand situation is the availability of local talent in the target market. The company may be unable to find talented and specialized people in its home country who are readily available in the target markets (Yonezawa, 2020). These personnel may provide the organization with additional benefits and help it gain a competitive advantage in the market.

Firm strategy structure and rivalry

Business is developing and growing, as seen by the firm’s strategy structure and rivalry across national borders. By entering the international market, the company can broaden its global effect and reach new customers (Horner, 2016). This will help the company’s brand name and appeal on a global scale. Goodwill is a valuable intangible asset that a company can easily acquire through global expansion.

Reasons for choosing the target market

Pakistan’s retail industry grew at a breakneck pace, accounting for more than 20% of the country’s GDP. With a population of 220 million, the market has enormous potential, particularly as consumption continues to grow. The retail sector in Pakistan has almost doubled in size during the previous decade. The economy is well-positioned for expansion, owing to the recent surge of technology and internet adoption. It employs 15% of the workforce and is the third-biggest industry and the second-largest employer in the nation. There are around 2 million merchants in Pakistan, with about 0.8 million working in contemporary trade and general commerce, such as grocery stores, general stores, medical stores, supermarkets, and hypermarkets, which sell fast-moving consumer products.

Macro environmental evolution

Pestle analysis

Pakistan has been subjected to a thorough examination. Pakistan is a Muslim-ruled country in South Asia. China, Iran, Afghanistan, India, the Gulf of Oman, and the Arabian Sea border it. Islamabad is Pakistan’s capital, and Karachi is the country’s largest city.

Political

Governing the country are the Prime Minister and Deputy PM, who are both elected by their respective parliaments and serve as de facto leaders. To have a multiparty parliamentary system, the three main political parties are all vital members. In spite of some promising and less promising times lately, Pakistan has a solid relationship with the US. Numerous political observers, then again, have scrutinized the tactical foundation’s predominance in Pakistani governmental issues. Pakistan’s neighbour and superpower, China, keeps up with solid, strategic, and business attaches with Pakistan.

Economics

According to Trading Economics, Pakistan’s GDP in 2019 was around US$320 billion (2020). A top 25 global economy by 2025 and one of the world’s 10 most prosperous countries by 2047 are both realistic goals for Pakistan. Pakistan’s financial growth should be aided by increasing FDI inflows and giving domestic financial supporters greater authority to spend money there. Countries such as Japan, the United Kingdom and Hong Kong are the country’s primary financial backers. Countless nations are burdened with heavy responsibilities (Saudi Arabia, USA), that’s why there will be a restriction on Lidl’s operations in Pakistan.

Social

The populace is expected to arrive at 219 million by March 2020. Islam is the most broadly polished religion, with Christianity and Hinduism representing just a small part of the populace. English, Urdu, Punjabi, Sindhi, Pashto, and Balochi are the most notable tongues (BBC, 2019). Pakistan, then again, is at present managing a large number of monetary issues. The Lidl strategic manager must assess any strategy before adopting it. Pakistanis should not accept alcoholic items and beverages such as beer. Pakistani Muslims are also opposed to anything made from pigs. Lidl should exclusively sell non-alcoholic products as a result.

Technological

Pakistan has made huge logical and innovative progressions throughout the long term. An assortment of online traders is flourishing in the nation, and Alibaba’s presentation has been hailed as a major lift to the country’s advanced economy. Lidl now has the opportunity to maintain an automated supply chain in Pakistan. The absence of Internet networks in numerous areas has eased back advanced development.

Legal

The legitimate climate of Pakistan is the last theme to be talked about in the PESTEL examination. Working hours ought not to surpass 8-9 hours of the day and 48 hours out of every week. No big natural disasters have occurred in Pakistan. Lidl now has a chance to operate in Pakistan without risk. When making judgments, managers should keep this element in mind.

Environmental

Pakistan is renowned for its social variety, mountains, archaeological destinations, and superb friendliness; regardless, the travel industry area has not benefited however much it ought to because of unfortunate lawfulness conditions. Ecological change, water shortage, the absence of satisfactory drinking water, deforestation, air contamination, squandering, and the utilization of plastic packs are all regular worries in Pakistan (Huma, 2018). Essentially, Covid-19 is relied upon to have a critical true effect.

Problems identification

This may be a difficult task for organization and corporations that operate on a global scale. For the rapidly increasing business sector, subsidiaries would hire talented individuals with autonomy in operations. It can be exceedingly tough to start a business while also recruiting employees. The subsidiary recruiting staff is under more stress and strain as a result of this (Schmidt, 2019). Before the procedure can be finished, the hiring process may differ from that in the country thus the hiring team must educate themselves.

Culture

Another issue that the subsidiary is dealing with is the cultural management of personnel through various training approaches. This is crucial for increasing production and reducing risk. The company’s management should have a friendly attitude toward the workers because they are Pakistani (Djrup, 2019). A homogeneous corporate culture in the workplace, which favours both British and Pakistani employees, poses a problem for the company.

Expatriates

When doing business abroad, the parent company has a significant difficulty. Businesses may choose the wrong business partner and face management issues as a result (Hoffmann, 2019). Because the subsidiary is new to the market and unfamiliar with the fundamentals of the business, the partner may be able to take advantage of it. As a result, selecting the correct partner to conduct business within another country is crucial.

The financial burden for each of A, B, C

It also increased from 1.489 to 1.675 to 2.078 by 2020, the firm’s equity multiplier. Growth in total assets outpaced growth in total equity during the period (Kimmel & Weygandt, 2021). Since its inception, the time’s interest earned ratio has fallen to 6.746 times, then to 2.078 times in 2021.  

Lidl business
RATIO ANALYSIS
	2019	2020	2021
LIQUIDITY RATIO S
Current ratio	1.4958	1.6786	1.0801
Cash ratio	1.4753	1.6382	1.0468
Receivables turnover	1.064 times	1.062 times	1.134  times
Inventory turnover	122.5 times	83.45 times	57.94  times
SOLVENCY RATI OS
Total debt ratio	0.3286	0.4031	0.5189
Times interest earned	9.367 times	6.746 times	3.614  times
Debt to equity ratio	0.489	0.675	1.078
Equity multiplier	1.489 times	1.675 times	2.078  times
PROFITABILITY R ATIOS
Asset turnover	0.975	0.8923	0.833
Profit margin	0.267	0.217	0.217
Return on assets(ROA	0.237	0.179	0.17
Return on Equity (ROE	0.489	0.3	0.354

Liquidity Ratios

The company’s current ratio gauges Lidl’s business ability to fulfil its short-term commitments. As a general rule of thumb, a suitable current ratio is two times. To 1.0801 in 2021, it dropped. Because the company’s total current liabilities grew faster than its total current assets in 2019, the drop in 2019 was attributed to this. 2013 saw a 7.2 per cent increase in Lidl’s business sales, while 2021 saw a slightly lower growth rate of 7 per cent to reach $182,795,000.

Over three years, operational earnings rose significantly. Lidl business stockholders’ net income declined by 11.3 per cent in 2019, although it rose by 6.7 per cent from $39,510,000 in 2014 to $55,763,000 this year. There was a 32.4 per cent rise in research and development costs in 2020; it grew another 35 per cent. Between 2020 and 2021, the E&T (earnings before interest and taxes) fell 10.1 per cent, although they rose by an additional 6.6 per cent in 2020.  

Lidl business
Statement of financial position analysis (Figures  in thousands  of USD)
Item	2012	2013	2014
Current Assets
Cash And Cash Equivalents	0.061	0.0689	0.0597
Short Term Investments	0.1044	0.127	0.0485
Net Receivables	0.1208	0.1164	0.136
Inventory	0.0045	0.0085	0.0091
Other Current Assets	0.0367	0.0332	0.0423
Total Current Assets	0.3275	0.354	0.2956
Long Term Investments	0.5232	0.5131	0.5614
Property Plant and Equipment	0.0878	0.0802	0.089
Goodwill	0.0064	0.0076	0.0199
Intangible Assets	0.024	0.0202	0.0179
Other Assets	0.0311	0.0249	0.0162
Total Assets	1.0000	1.0000	1.0000
Liabilities
Current Liabilities
Accounts Payable	0.1851	0.175	0.2098
Other Current Liabilities	0.0338	0.0359	0.0638
Total Current Liabilities	0.2189	0.2109	0.2737
Other Liabilities	0.0946	0.1796	0.2321
Deferred Long Term Liability Charge	0.015	0.0127	0.0131
Total Liabilities	0.3286	0.4031	0.5189
Stockholders’ Equity
Common Stock	0.0933	0.0955	0.1006
Retained Earnings	0.5753	0.5037	0.3759
Other Stockholder Equity	0.0028	-0.0023	0.0047
Total Stockholder Equity	0.6714	0.5969	0.4811
Net Tangible Assets	0.641	0.569	0.4434

The net tangible assets for Lidl’s business started at 64.1% in 2019, but they fell to 56.9% in 2020. In 2021, they fell further to 44.34% to close at $112,851,000. The proportion of the net tangible assets decreased over the years. The other shareholder’s equity increased by 4.52% in 2021 and decreased by 9.71% in 2019 to close at $499,000. Retained earnings increased by 2.93% in 2021, but they decreased by 16.41% to close at $101,289,000. A decline in the financial strength of Lidl’s business is proven through the decline in its statement of financial position items. 

Recommendation

Lidl must overcome the obstacles and challenges listed above, as well as manage its global operations successfully via its subsidiaries. For its Pakistani subsidiary, the organization should recruit appropriate staff. Besides, the organization should address preparing and the executive’s challenges at the abroad auxiliary, as well as select a reliable accomplice. The following are some possible options in this regard:

• Pakistani businesses have developed a strategy of employing graduates from universities and different vocational colleges. This approach is referred to as “new graduate recruiting.”
• Training and management of employees should be phased in order to address each individual’s concerns and inquiries. Certain workers may be ambitious or fast to pick up new skills. Organizations ought to give hands-on preparation to these representatives. This method helps workers to work in a pleasant environment.
• It is vital to choose the appropriate partner when establishing a subsidiary in another nation. The primary criteria are the partner’s capacity to supply complementary resources and capabilities to the parent company (Dinca, 2019).

Implantation

Strategic Methods of entry and possible consequences

Businesses may use one of two strategies to expand their market in Pakistan, depending on the economic climate. A direct export is the first option, while a partnership/joint venture is the second.

Direct exportation:

Lidl may use this strategy to export products directly to Pakistani customers, avoiding local producers or middlemen. Businesses would then operate as a distribution channel for the parent corporation, selling products via retail channels to end consumers. Because the risk would be significantly reduced, this strategy would confer several benefits on the parent organization.

Joint Venture/Partnership:

Complex strategic or co-marketing alliances are only two examples of partnership types. An advanced strategic partnership between local and worldwide businesses might be formed in this case, according to the company (Ahmed, 2019). Pakistani clients’ likes and preferences are well-understood by the company, which is able to provide locally tailored goods on an international scale. Corporations that follow this approach might put more focus on local responsiveness and autonomy for their subsidiaries.

Due to the fact that direct exporting is a low-risk approach, Lidl plans to explore this option.

References

ADV_Ratings, (2021). Among the top 10 retail chains of the UK. [Online] Available at: https://www.advratings.com/europe/top-banks-in-the-Uk,

Ahmed, L., (2019). The impact of Founder’s human capital on firms’ extent of early internationalization: Evidence from a least-developed country. Asia Pacific Journal of Management, pp. 615-659.

BBC, (2019). Pakistan country profile, s.l.: BBC News.

Bowen, R., (2019). Motives to SME internationalization: Cross Cultural & Strategic Management. s.l.:s.n.

Dinca, C., (2019). Challenges regarding the internationalization of universities from Scotland, within the Brexit landscape.

Djørup, S., (2019). The institutionalization of zero transaction cost theory: a case study in Danish district heating regulation. Evolutionary and Institutional Economics Review, pp. 1-16.

Hoffmann, C., (2019). Economic Rationality, the Transaction Cost Theory, and Morality. An Extended Approach. zfwu Zeitschrift für Wirtschafts-und Unternehmensethik, pp. 31-51.

Horner, D., (2016). The role of psychic distance in internationalization strategy evaluations and strategic choices. Journal of Business Strategies, p. 17.

Huma, Z., (2018). Pakistan’s environmental challenges.

Available at: https://dailytimes.com.pk/247550/pakistans-environmental-challenges/

Khawaja, A., (2021). What are the problems faced by the retail sector in Pakistan? [Online] Available at: https://macropakistani.com/retail-sector-in-pakistan/

Kossev, K., (2019). Promises and challenges: Internationalization of the transition economies, s.l.: New Eastern Europe.

Nuruzzaman, A., (2020). Institutional support, hazards, and internationalization of emerging market firms. Global Strategy Journal, pp. 361-385.

Parida, P., (2016). Transaction costs theory and coordinated safeguards investment in R&D offshoring. Journal of Business Research, pp. 1823-1833.

Schmidt, S., (2019). Blockchain and supply chain relations: A transaction cost theory perspective. Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management, p. 100552.

Stat CounterS, (2020). Social Media Stats Pakistan. Available at: https://gs.statcounter.com/social-media-stats/all/pakistan.